Conquest Chronicles: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Around SBN: Interview With UMD Athletic Director, Dr. Debbie Yow

Under Pressure

In what can only be described as a sense of urgency the NCAA allowed itself to be interviewed by L.A. Times about why it is taking so long to get both the Bush and Mayo situations headed to form of resolution.

The Bush investigation has stretched past two years and the Mayo case, launched in May, could extend into 2009, reviving questions about the NCAA's ability and even willingness to police its member schools.

Mindful of such criticisms, Price and several of his 29 investigators recently agreed to address -- in general terms -- how they respond to potential violations

Part of the problem is that the NCAA has no subpoena power. They have no authority to compel a former Student-Athlete to testify, yet without all the information they can pass judgment and punish an institution with nary a hint of due process. The bigger problem is that because they can pass down judgment with little to no due process and that can make for some interesting allegations.

The NCAA also has what Price calls "tools of authority," its bylaws requiring cooperation from coaches, administrators and athletes still on the team.

"I'm not going to sit here and tell you that everyone is truthful with us," Price said. "But if they lie, they do so at considerable risk.

An unethical conduct charge could render an athlete ineligible or cost a coach his job.

With these "tools," and a subsequent committee hearing not bound by law, some say the NCAA wields too much power.

"They do not have to give you any of the due process rights guaranteed under the Constitution," said Thomas Gallion, an attorney who represented two Alabama football assistants in a 2002 case.

"You have someone who can put a college program out of business and ruin a coach," Gallion said. "You can understand that every coach, every administration lives in fear of them."

Amen!

Nobody really knows what motivates a person. The case of Louis Johnson is to me is a better example of that than Lloyd Lake. Johnson claimed he was only coming forward to protect O.J. because he didn’t want to see O.J. harmed further by the hangers-on that allegedly got him into this mess.

What doesn’t wash with me is that Johnson only came forward after he was booted from the gravy train not while he was on it. Johnson coming forward actually hurt OJ more in the level of scrutiny that Mayo will receive, the potential in lost endorsements and the damage to his reputation so I’m not buying into Johnson’s benevolence.

More to the point...

The Bush and Mayo cases epitomize an increasingly common situation, the NCAA chasing after marketers, financial consultants and runners, the shadowy figures who represent sports agents. This isn't like a coach handing over cash. These people operate on the fringe of college sports, where NCAA investigators have no subpoena power and no legal recourse against those who might lie.

The term “Lack of Institutional Control” gets thrown around like dollar bills at a strip club while having a loose definition. What an institution should or shouldn’t know really is going to be the crux of the matter. As we have said before and institution can't know everything it's players do so how are they going to know if their family is  committing an infraction, especially if the infraction is taking place far away of the watchful eyes of the institution. The NCAA is powerless to address these incidents, they won't fight for new legislation anymore than they will fight to have existing laws enforced.

This article is nothing more than the NCAA telling us what we already know, that they don't have enough information to move forward and moving forward without all the info, especially if they are wrong, further damages their authority.

There is nothing really new here, outside of little more gamesmanship from Lake's attorney. It's more like the classic case of C.Y.A.

0 recs  |  Comment 1 comment

Story-email Email Printer Print

More from Conquest Chronicles

DeRozan IS Coming to USC

Jun 2008 by Paragon SC - 0 comments

Katz on Mayo

May 2008 by Paragon SC - 0 comments

Around SB Nation

Comments

Display:

what is the ncaa really

They are just a bunch of professors ( who profit from extra money for working for NCAA ) who can’t play sports and can’t work in the real world. I can’t see them cutting off the head of the beast that they have created, so this all a big joke and think of all the state school money that has been wasted on this joke of an issue. Maybe they can get BN some new handicap parking passes.

by so.cal.native1952 on Jul 14, 2008 11:37 PM PDT reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to Conquest Chronicles the SB Nation blog about the USC Trojans.

Community Guidelines
Start posting about the Trojans »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Images_small
2010 USC Baseball Season Preview

Recent FanPosts

Smoove1_small
"Big Question marks" about next years USC team
Pk1_001_small
Ucla FB and the Clippers
Untitled_small
David Sills' recruitment: The joke is on bRuins
Galloping_horses_small
From the Helicopter Pilot
Jackburton_small
Kiffin gets a head start on his 2015 class
Spqr_small
Top Questions For USC Coaches From UCLA Type Players
Jk_small
Non-Revenue Sports Coverage
4759_114276103488_551713488_1998274_134838_n_small
Great Read On Seantrel
Pk1_001_small
Looks like Trojan Mens Tennis team is starting off season with a bang!

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Sponsors


Managers

4759_114276103488_551713488_1998274_134838_n_small Paragon SC

Avatar2_small DC Trojan

Official Partner of CBS Sports